I used to do graphite portraits of people and everyone was happy except one, and that was from a woman whose son had died. Now I do pet portraits in ink wash or watercolors and hit on the money every time, except today. Her pets died and she wanted a nice memory. They all say they all love the eyes 🙄 so I was sure to get a nice close-up of her dogs' eyes. She doesn't feel Ike it looks like her dog. Luckily I only did one before approval. The second she wants a combination of two photos. I offered her a refund and both she and I are sad she isn't happy. I think if I didn't nail this one, there's no chance that the second one is going to look exact since I would be having to use my judgement to combine them. I am attaching (I hope since I have never used this forum before) the painting and the photo. I told her art is subjective and it won't be as dynamic if I just traced it and tried to duplicate the photo exactly.
So my question? Can you ever make someone happy whose subject has passed or is it just me?